Thursday, April 16, 2009
Gay Marriage Rights
I do not think that the reasoning behind having same-sex marriages has any logical sense or actual support behind it. In my opinion, the reason it is illegal in most states is because the beliefs of many people. To me, it's very hypocritical to outlaw gay marriage because of all the things America says it stands for. We pride ourselves on all humans have equal opportunities and rights, but we don't live up to our promotions. There is no proof that a gay couple is any less capable of being a family than a man and a women is, and thats something that you can never really prove. The real basis for same-sex marriages really boils down to prejudice. When we look back on history and see things such as segregation and slavery it looks completely ridiculous to us, and we cannot even fathom why our government and people thought those things were okay. All of these things all have the common thread of prejudice and judgment running threw them. However, over time as seen from many events in history we tend to get over these judgmental attitudes and get rid of these things that portray inequality. I think it will be the same revelation when my kids look back on history books and see things such as how gay marriage was illegal.
Tuesday, April 14, 2009
Engaging the Text # 5
In the supreme court case, Turner v. Safley, it was decided that Missouri could not arbitrarily deny marriage rights to prisoners. A group of prisoners was previously denied the right of marriage, but the supreme court took back this decision once they went over the importance of what marriage represents. They established that it was was a public statement of love, it has many serious religious importance to people, it offers the prospect of physical "consummation", and it comes with many protections, responsibilities, and benefits that are a big importance to people. All this said, same-sex marriage is still not legal in Missouri. Wolfson uses this as a comparison to how ridiculous it is that prisoners are given the extremely important decision of marriage versus people who have not committed crimes and are truly in love and have been together for a long period of time and wish to express that love with an official commitment. People who wish to have same-sex marriage have the same goals and wants as every other person in society, but yet they are denied a simple right over criminals. This is an important case to make because it shows how unreasonable the issues of same-sex marriage actually is. It also places it into perspective that some people would actually rather give criminals rights over citizens who have done nothing wrong, and shines a light on how hypocritical and messed up our governmental system can actually be.
Monday, April 13, 2009
Airplane Metaphor
Dr. Horn believes that a family with a mother and a father in a healthy marriage is compared to an airplane that always reaches its destination, and a family with a single parent is compared to a plane that only sometimes reaches its destination. To me, this is a very opinionated and awkward metaphor to use to express this idea. First of all I don't really think that there are some planes that are more unreliable than others or "sometimes" reach their destination, because those are the planes that have crashed and are no longer functional at all. Dr. Horn then goes on to say that everyone would choose the first plane, and in the context of planes of course they would, but I am sure there are many people who are more than satisfied with being raised by single parent. I really think that what depends more on the success of a child is how it is parented rather than who or how many people are parenting them. I know many people who have parents with a healthy marriage, but fail when it comes to parenting . It all depends on how you go about raising your child.
Vazquez
I think Vazquez waits to disclose that they are actually straight men to emphasize the point that the hate crimes are purely judgmental based on looks more then the actual personality of a person. In both Brian and Mickey's stories they never talked or even looked at the people who attacked him. The reasoning that that they must be gay was of what they were wearing, and the atmosphere they found themselves in. She then lets us in on the fact that they are not actually gay. As a reader we are not expecting this, and it shines a heavy light on how these acts of violence can be potentially dangerous to everyone. It puts hate crimes on a whole different level when we realize that there is no logical reasoning for them, and purely have to do with appearance. The issue of the violence does change when you realize that they are heterosexual because it now posses not only a threat to homosexual people, but straight people that are reading this as well. People are not as effected when they are reading if they are heterosexual because they don't feel like it has to do with their life. But, when she discloses that this is a threat to all then people actually get upset.
Thursday, April 9, 2009
Transcendentalism
I think that Eustace did share some of the common threads as transcendentalist believed in, but i don't think he was one. Transcendentalist believe that humans are were divine because they were a part of nature, and that all nature shared one soul in common with humans. This was a very spiritual way of thinking that i don't think Eustace had. Although, he was very spiritual in that he did believe God created nature and spent much time praying, he did not think nature to be spiritual. However, Transcendentalist did believe that human did not have a limit on their capabilities and that if you fail at something it is because a lack of effort. Eustace definitely had thins way of thinking. He put no limits on what he could accomplish, and would push himself until he achieve what he set out to do. Many people found him controlling and harsh, but this was because Eustace hated when people failed at something because they were lazy. Eustace did share some common idea with the Transcendentalist, but overall I don't think he was one. I mean you never saw Emerson or Thoreau running around killing animals and living purely on the land. I think Gilbert had this same idea as well. She classified him more as someone that was mainly concerned about the maintaining nature, rather than coming up with complex ideas about the divine soul behind it.
Tuesday, April 7, 2009
Emerson's Nature
One sentence within this essay that Emerson wrote that i found particularly strong and meaningful was, "I become a transparent eye-ball; I am nothing; I see all; the currents of the Universal Being circulate through me; i am part or particle of God." This describes Emerson's feelings he has when he goes to the woods and leave his identity within society behind. There is know one in the woods that can judge him, or disrupt the world that God created. To him nature is pure and is the quintessence of what being one with God means to him. Nature is the only thing left on earth in his view that has not been corrupted. When he goes to the woods the problems in society like fortune, fame, and many different evils do not exist simple because nature is a whole different world apart from human corruption. So, when he goes to the woods he slips out of his identify that the rest of society sees him to be and no longer exists as far as the rest of the humanity is concerned. He becomes one with the purest form of the earth away from all materialistic corruption.
Monday, April 6, 2009
The Last American Man
I think Elizabeth Gilbert wrote this book to bring praise to what she thinks is that last man in America who is living their life to it's fullest potential without the need of societies help. This brings light to the idea that it is possible to live without all the necessities we have become so accustomed to. When Gilbert describes Eustace Conway she makes him seem to be almost inhuman in that he fears nothing, and there is nothing that he cannot do. The first time Gilbert describes him she states, "He is wildly competent, He is physically and intellectually predestined to acquire proficiency. He has perfect eyesight, perfect hearing, perfect balance, perfect reflexes, and perfect focus. he has long muscles on a light but strongly constructed frame, like a natural middle-distance runner. His body can do anything he asks of it. His mind, too" (17). This description leaves us thinking that this man has no flaws, and it almost seems like he is too perfect to be a real human. She wants us to think that he is the last of his kind. Within the story we do see that Eustace has flaws such as control and a need to do everything to it's fullest or else it is not acceptable in his eyes. One one hand, this could possibly take away from his perfection. But, I think that she added his control issues in the book to prove that he is on top of everything he does in life, and that he must do everything perfectly to be satisfied.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)